Climate Change

Not quite COP-ing?

Good afternoon from New Economy Brief

The world’s great, good, and the rest are currently gathered in Antalya, Türkiye, for the second week of this year’s UN climate talks, COP31. This week we explore what’s on the negotiating table in a context of geopolitical instability and rising climate impacts.

‍

Global climate talks in extraordinary times

The climate COPs are ‘Conferences of the Parties’ of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). They are the centerpiece of UNFCCC negotiations, with fierce battles raging over key decisions that must be agreed by consensus.

This year’s is in many ways an unprecedented COP. For the first time, two countries are sharing hosting responsibilities: Türkiye leading on operations while Australia takes on the (less appealing) formal negotiations. It also is the first COP since any country formally exited the 1992 UNFCCC treaty. The USA left in January this year, and sent no formal delegation for the second year running. Despite this, 20 Democrats went along anyway following their midterms success.

In the words of the UN climate chief, COP31 takes place in ‘a new world disorder’. A new war in the Middle East has caused an historic energy and food supply shock and unleashed another round of scarcity-induced inflation. The head of the International Energy Agency recently argued the unprecedented alignment between energy security and climate objectives brought on by this instability will fuel greater climate ambition. But the pressure to rearm is already causing governments such as the UK to cut climate spending to manage rising defence budgets.  

‍

The big-ticket agenda items

This year we can watch political-economic tensions over how to respond to climate change play out in real time. One of the key disputes is whether to start immediately cutting fossil fuel production (‘supply-side’ climate policy), or to build out alternatives first (a build-then-break approach). 

Electrification is a priority for this year’s hosts, who want nations to collectively pledge to increase electricity’s share in global energy delivered to end users to 35% by 2035 (dubbed ‘35-by-35’). Türkiye and Australia, neither of which has a coal phase-out date, have excluded transitioning away from fossil fuels (TAFF) from their priorities and pre-COP communications. COP30 host Brazil brought a proposal for a global ‘roadmap’ to the talks, and TAFF language did appear in the cover text’s first draft on Monday, but climate policy expert Tzeporah Berman predicted this would ‘last about 2 minutes’.

Another focus will be determining the functions, resources, and governance of the ‘Belem-Antalaya Just Transition Mechanism’ (BAM). This is a centralised UNFCCC structure to support workers and communities in the shift to a low-carbon economy that was a major win for civil society at COP30. A coalition of over 700 organisations called for the mechanism to centre on rights and justice, provide technical and financial support, and represent marginalised groups. The first text on the topic suggests ambition may be much lower than these groups were hoping. 

International climate finance has always been contentious, ever since the Paris Agreement obliged wealthier countries to provide financial assistance to poorer and more vulnerable ones. This is to help them reduce emissions (mitigation), build resilience to future climate hazards (adaptation), and compensate them for loss and damage from unavoidable impacts. Many funding pledges have already expired, but domestic cost-of-living and fiscal pressures are making international aid commitments more politically difficult. Several major countries have delayed announcing new funding ahead of COP31.

‍

Who’s at the party and what do they want? 

Major leaders are conspicuously absent this year. Just 14% of greenhouse gas emissions were represented by heads of state, with Andy Burnham the only G7 leader to attend. In his speech, Burnham publicly reaffirmed his commitment to net zero by 2050 as a national security priority, but has previously emphasised that this cannot come at the expense of people’s ability to afford essentials. The UK’s recent approval of a new gas field and rumours it will dilute its electric vehicles mandate led to criticism of its climate leadership ahead of the talks.

Brazil’s President Lula also addressed COP31 in his first international engagement since his dramatic election comeback. Under Lula, Brazilian diplomats previously called for a 2% wealth tax on billionaires to tackle climate change and its links to wealth inequality. This year, he instead emphasised action needed on climate finance, fossil fuel transition, and deforestation, including more funding for the under-capitalised Tropical Forests Forever Facility - a public-private financial mechanism designed to reward countries rich in forest for protecting it. 

Poorer countries on the frontline of climate impacts are heavily focused on adaptation. The G77 and China bloc - the largest coalition of developing nations at the talks - also publicly raised concerns regarding the ‘insufficiency, inaccessibility and very low availability of climate finance’ from developed countries. The quality of climate finance is particularly central, as loan-based instruments can exacerbate the ‘climate-debt’ trap that these nations already face. 

‍

What’s at stake?

This year saw some of the most extreme weather in recent history. Europe faced a record-breaking heatwave. A glacier collapse in Nepal – made more likely by climate change – killed at least 1,300 people in devastating floods, but Nepal’s claim under the loss and damage fund only covered 0.7% of costs. The levels of climate finance available clearly fail to meet the scale of today’s impacts, with a potential ‘super’ El Nino expected to turbocharge disasters even further. 

A temporary overshoot of the Paris Agreement’s 1.5C limit is probably inevitable, according to the UN. Focus is shifting towards keeping it as short and small as possible through rapid mitigation, since the severity of impacts increases with every fraction of a degree, including the threat of tipping points. There are some plausible grounds for hope. Scientists now consider the worst-case, highest-emission pathway used in standardised climate scenarios to be implausible due to progress in climate policy and global fossil CO2 emissions are set to fall in 2026.

‍

What’s next?

Monday saw the first draft of the political ‘cover text’ that countries will negotiate alongside other procedural and governance items, likely until late Friday evening. Ethiopia will host on behalf of the African Union in 2027. The second ‘global stocktake’ of the Paris Agreement’s implementation will conclude at COP33 in 2028. China has since backed away from last week’s rumours it would bid to host. 

Antonio Guterres, a sharp critic of the fossil fuel lobby, will close out his term as UN Secretary General next month. Tuvalu and Ireland will co-host the second international conference on fossil fuel phase-out next summer, an alternative space to COP for a coalition of the willing to focus on specific systems over unanimous emissions targets. The Democrats’ midterm success amid widespread opposition to data centres and rising energy prices may allow state-level progress on climate and energy policy; an election win in 2028 could see a US return to COP. In the face of increasingly unignorable global impacts, there is an urgent need to get all the players back on the pitch to tackle climate change together.

Weekly Updates

Work and welfare

A new settlement for young people? Tuesday saw the long-awaited release of the Milburn review on young people not in education, employment, or training (NEETs). The New Economics Foundation set out five tests for the government’s response and suggested that while there is ‘much to welcome’, it doesn’t do enough to address the fundamental lack of opportunities for young people across the UK.

Climate change and inflation

UK firms pass on costs from extreme weather to food consumers. The Autonomy Institute launched its Risks to British Business (RtBB) tool that analyses UK company filings in Companies House, with a first report on extreme weather risks in food production. Large firms operating across several geographies, in particular, have more ability to absorb crop failures and can profit when weather shifts increase food prices, while small farms and food businesses struggle to stay afloat.

Digital platforms and international cooperation

Pooling capabilities with middle powers to build UK digital sovereignty. IPPR published a ‘realist’s agenda’ for how the UK can better control and shape the digital technologies it relies on. It explores feasible scenarios of control across three strands: resilience to shifts in access or suppliers; creating and keeping more value from technology domestically; and access to, and governance of, the most advanced AI models. 

Image: